Friday, January 25, 2008

Read-a-Thon

By Rebecca Talley

The Parent-Teacher Organization (PTO) at my children’s elementary school is sponsoring a Read-a-Thon. The goal for the school is 120,000 minutes in two weeks. The goal for each of the older kids is 800 minutes. Kids receive medals each day at certain minute intervals of 100, 200, 400, 600 and 800. The medals resemble dog tags and the kids wear them on chains provided by the school.

The kids are excited. My older daughter has already read 800 minutes and we still have another week. My son, who started school this year, reads with me and on his own and has logged over 200 minutes. My other daughter has read almost 500 minutes. My three nieces have read a combined 2500 minutes. All of this reading is fabulous. We have a school filled with kids that are choosing to read. They’re talking about books. They're thinking about books. Most of all, they're reading books.

Today is Character Day. Each child comes dressed as a character in a book they’ve read. It’s wonderful to hear such buzz about books and reading.

Did I mention this is also a fundraiser? Ideally, each child is supposed to secure sponsors and earn money for the school. A lot of money. The more money, the better. Earning money while reading seems like the perfect idea because it’s a win-win situation. Almost.

Winners will receive prizes. The student who earns the most money wins a mountain bike. The next runner-up wins a telescope. The other runners-up win assorted prizes donated by local merchants. Sounds good, right? Kids are reading, winning prizes, and earning money for the school.

Now, here is the discrepancy, at least to me. The students who read more than 1000 minutes receive tickets for a drawing that includes a punch-pass to the local recreation center. Not a bike or a telescope and not even a guarantee to win the prize for the student who reads the most minutes, only tickets for a drawing.

Many of the kids have concluded that money is more important than reading and that money earned is better rewarded than the actual reading. (I would also note that the same kid wins the "most money earned" each year because his parents donate a lot of money).

Is this the message we want to send to our kids, that money is more important than reading?

Some of the kids have also pointed out that they can control how much time they spend reading. They can make the choice to read instead of watch TV or play video games. Isn’t that the kind of choice we’d like to encourage?

These same kids have also mentioned that they cannot control how much someone is willing to donate. The actual fundraising is out of their hands. They can only control how much time they spend reading, they can’t force people to pay money for it.

While the idea of a Read-a-Thon is great, I believe the execution is somewhat flawed. Last year a child read well over 2000 minutes. She was awarded a pass to the recreation center (worth about$30). The boy who raised the most money (his actual reading minutes were never disclosed) won an expensive mountain bike. Wrong message.

We should be encouraging our children to read for the simple joy of reading. I understand the PTO needs to raise funds. What the PTO doesn’t understand is that if the emphasis was placed on the actual reading, and raising funds was secondary, a lot more money would be raised because parents like me would be more supportive.

The ability to read is a gift we give our children. It should never be underestimated, nor undermined by anything else, not even a school fundraiser.

5 comments:

  1. Rebecca, I am with you 100% on this subject. Reading should be the bigger emphasis. Grrrr...I felt like a boxer warming up to enter the ring as I read your post...it got my dander up!W had something similar happen with a jump-a-thon. I thought the emphasis was supposed to be about teaching fitness and health. It turned out to be more about the money.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My parents were both teachers. Reading was a very big thing in our family when I grew up. I followed through and made it a "big" thing with my children. And now I see my son and his wife doing the same with their children. Reading is a blessing that needs to be shared.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's been frustrating, but we're hoping to change things next year. My niece composed a letter about it and lots of kids signed it and then she presented it to the principal. I guess we'll see.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I hope the petition works. In my opinion, reading should be about reading and encouraging kids to read, NOT about making money.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ladies, I whole-heartedly agree with all of you that the importance of reading, fitness, etc. should be the main message that the children receive when they participate in a Walk-a-Thons, Read-a-Thon, etc. However, the main objective for a fundraiser is just that -- raising funds. The beauty of marrying something beneficial for the children (i.e. reading, fitness) and raising money to provide things for the children (i.e. computers, playground equipment, books) is just the kind of fundraiser I will participate in. If you ask me and my children to sell candy, candles, cookie dough, wrapping paper or some other item that no one needs, I will say no. But,if you ask me and my children to join in a program that promotes health or literacy and also raises money for our school, then I will give you a definite yes. As for the very unequal prizes that were mentioned, that is something the school should address. Two top prizes of equal value -- one for the most minutes read and one for the most donations secured -- would be more fair.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for visiting. Feel free to comment on our blogger's posts.*

*We do not allow commercial links, however. If that's not clear, we mean "don't spam us with a link to your totally unrelated-to-writing site." We delete those comments.